Hospitals, hospitals, everywhere

2010
06.07

There are 6 hospitals within a six mile radius of downtown Trenton – four “regular” hospitals, a children’s hospital, a prison hospital and a psych hospital.  If you expand that radius just a little, you can pick up two university hospitals and another children’s hospital also.  So either the people of this area are really sick or are paying too much for health care that they can support this many hospitals.  So there are also two hospitals under construction and one more being talked about.  These will replace existing hospitals and not add to the count, but in this economy, that’s a lot of dollars going to construction!!!

Now before I take this post into a rant about health care and insurance, let’s steer it back to architecture – both ongoing and potential.

Capital Health is relocating one of it’s two hospitals in Trenton out to Hopewell (the suburbs) for all the usual reasons – parking, highway access, keeping the suburbanites from having the horror of going into the city.  Here is an image of the project as of April 2010.   Click the image to see the project’s website.

Captial Health Hopewell

Captial Health Hopewell as of April 2010

The University Medical Center at Princeton is currently located in Princeton and is both landlocked and having issues with access (narrow roads, lots of university traffic), so they acquired a large plot of land just off Route 1 in Plainsboro and are under construction with hopes of opening in 2011.

Princeton Health

Artists Rendering of the new Princeton Hospital

Another hospital, St. Francis, has been talking about a construction project, although it’s still just in the planning phase now.

So, the two hospitals have their own architectural significance, but in addition, there will now be two old hospitals in dense urban areas that need to be re-purposed or redeveloped.  Now’s the time for these two communities to help steer the projects that will fill the voids left by these two hospitals (and their associated medical offices around them).  Princeton has a school of architecture that may play a role in the exploration of their site (at least as a studio project) and a thriving downtown that will help naturally fill the gaps, but Trenton doesn’t have those advantages.  Maybe The College of New Jersey’s Municipal Land Use Center can explore the potential of Trenton’s space.

Anyone familiar with these locations have any development ideas / suggestions for the redevelopment?

If you enjoyed this post, please consider leaving a comment or subscribing to the RSS feed to have future articles delivered to your feed reader.

Tags: ,

  • http://32candles.com Ernessa from 32 CANDLES

    I don’t have any suggestions for this hospital, but I adore Huntington Hospital in Pasadena . It looks like a hotel with a front lobby/foyer and everything. Visiting people there is really calming and nice even under tough circumstances, and I’m a little sad we’re moving, b/c I’d love to deliver the next baby there. Seriously it’s THAT nice. I think all hospitals should take note.

    • http://intensedebate.com/people/architectblog architectblog

      Good design can definitely help ease the stress of being at a hospital, for the patients and the visitors. I think architecture plays an important role in our emotional well being, if done right.

  • Monique

    It is the reuse of the sites they are vacating that worries me. For exampke, I do not think the plan that has been developed for what will be the former Capital Health site is feasible. So what happens if the site just sits vacant? When hospitals vacate sites like these they should be held accountable for the development of a realistic reuse plan and some portion of that plan’s implementation.

  • architectblog

    They should, but they won’t be. In fact, the city will jump at the chance to take over the site as-is, then they will sit on it for decades as they figure out what to do, then they will do a half-ass job redeveloping and make an even bigger mess of the area. It’s such a shame. Maybe someone with some redevelopment experience could start a development organization and get the property and handle it properly… just saying…

  • http://intensedebate.com/people/architectblog Brian V

    I fear that the new mayor and the new council will jump at taking over the empty property if offered by the hospital, then sit on it for decades. When it is finally dealt with, it will have further killed the neighborhood and it will be built out as low-end crap. Maybe someone with some economic development experience and some government connections could start a CDC to manage this project?